Maui’s Only Coin Shop: Buying, Selling, and Appraising Rare Coins
Every Coin Has a Story
Coins are much more than money. They represent history, artistry, and, in many cases, a family’s legacy. Over the years, we’ve met customers who inherited coin collections from their parents or grandparents, discovered old coins while cleaning out a safe, or simply wondered whether the coins sitting in a drawer were worth anything.
Some collections are worth a few hundred dollars, while others are worth thousands. The only way to know for certain is to have them professionally evaluated.
For nearly 50 years, Kamaʻāina Loan has been helping Maui residents understand the value of their coins. As Maui’s only dedicated coin shop, we’ve handled everything from a single collectible coin to large estate collections.
What Types of Coins Do We Buy?
We purchase and evaluate a wide variety of coins and precious metal products, including:
- Gold coins
- Silver coins
- Platinum coins
- American Gold Eagles
- American Silver Eagles
- American Gold Buffaloes
- Morgan Silver Dollars
- Peace Silver Dollars
- Walking Liberty Half Dollars
- Franklin Half Dollars
- Mercury Dimes
- Standing Liberty Quarters
- Pre-1965 U.S. silver coins
- Proof Sets
- Mint Sets
- Certified coins graded by PCGS or NGC
- Foreign coins
- Hawaiian Kingdom coins
- Gold bullion
- Silver bullion
- Estate coin collections
Whether you have a single coin or several boxes from an estate, we’re happy to evaluate your collection.
What Makes a Coin Valuable?
One of the most common questions we hear is:
“How much is my coin worth?”
The answer depends on several important factors.
Rarity
Some coins were produced in limited quantities, while others have become scarce because few remain in excellent condition. The rarer the coin, the greater its potential value.
Condition
Condition plays a major role in determining a coin’s value. Even small differences in wear, scratches, or cleaning can significantly affect what collectors are willing to pay.
Precious Metal Content
Many older U.S. coins contain silver or gold. Even common-date coins may be worth much more than their face value because of the precious metal they contain.
Collector Demand
Collector interest changes over time. Some coins become more desirable because of their rarity, historical importance, or growing popularity among collectors.
Every collection is unique, which is why every collection deserves an individual evaluation.
More Than Just Coins
In addition to collectible coins, we also buy and evaluate:
- Gold bullion bars
- Silver bullion bars
- Gold rounds
- Silver rounds
- Precious metal ingots
- Paper currency collections
- Estate collections
- Gold and silver investment products
If you’re not sure whether an item has value, bring it in. We’d be happy to take a look and answer your questions.
Honest Evaluations Based on Experience
Evaluating coins involves much more than looking up prices in a guidebook.
Our experienced staff carefully considers:
- Date
- Mint mark
- Condition
- Precious metal content
- Collector demand
- Certification
- Current market prices
We stay current with both the precious metals market and collector trends so our evaluations reflect today’s marketplace.
Our goal is simple: explain what you have, how we determined its value, and answer every question you may have.
Estate Collections Welcome
Many of the collections we evaluate come from estates. Family members often inherit coins without knowing whether they’re common or rare.
Before selling an inherited collection, it’s a good idea to have it professionally evaluated. Some collections contain overlooked rarities, while others derive most of their value from their gold or silver content.
We’ll carefully review your collection, identify important pieces, and explain what you have. There’s never any obligation to sell.
Why Collectors Trust Kamaʻāina Loan
For nearly 50 years, Kamaʻāina Loan has earned a reputation for honesty, knowledge, and exceptional customer service.
Customers visit us from Wailuku, Kahului, Kihei, Lahaina, Makawao, Pāʻia, Kula, Haʻikū, and communities throughout Maui because they know they’ll receive straightforward answers and fair evaluations.
We’re proud to offer:
- Nearly 50 years serving Maui
- Maui’s only dedicated coin shop
- Professional XRF precious metal testing
- Graduate Gemologist on staff
- Licensed Hawaii pawnbroker
- Honest, transparent evaluations
- Confidential transactions
- Convenient parking behind our Wailuku location
Whether you’re an experienced collector or looking through an inherited collection for the first time, we’ll take the time to explain exactly what you have.
Frequently Asked Questions
Do you buy entire coin collections?
Yes. We purchase collections of all sizes, from a single rare coin to large estate collections.
Do you buy gold and silver coins?
Absolutely. We regularly purchase American Eagles, Morgan Dollars, Peace Dollars, bullion coins, foreign coins, and many other collectible issues.
Can you identify rare coins?
Yes. We’ll examine your coins for important dates, mint marks, condition, certification, and collector demand to help determine their value.
Do you buy bullion?
Yes. We buy and sell gold bullion, silver bullion, investment bars, rounds, and many popular bullion coins.
Can I get an evaluation even if I’m not ready to sell?
Of course. Many customers simply want to understand what they own before making a decision. We’re always happy to answer questions and provide a professional evaluation.
Visit Maui’s Only Coin Shop
Whether you’re just beginning a collection, selling investment coins, or settling an estate, we’re here to help.
Bring your coins, bullion, or collection to Kamaʻāina Loan in Wailuku for a professional evaluation. We’ll explain what you have, discuss today’s market, and provide a fair assessment based on current values.
For nearly 50 years, Maui residents have trusted Kamaʻāina Loan for honest advice, knowledgeable service, and fair offers. We’d be honored to help you understand the value of your collection, whether you’re buying, selling, or simply curious about what you own.
